20 Best Places to Sell Baseball Cards in 2023

Baseball cards can be highly collectible. Many antique stores contain a wide variety of baseball cards.

One reason for baseball cards being collectible is that they have been around for a long time. Some baseball cards can be worth millions of dollars.

It is one thing to have a baseball card, it is another to know where to sell a baseball card either for cash or online. 

Have you been wondering where you can sell a baseball card? Have you been wondering what a baseball card is and what the types are?

In this article, you would learn the best places to sell baseball cards in 2023 and much more.

Keep reading. 

What Is a Baseball Card?

A baseball card is a type of trading card relating to baseball, usually printed on cardboard, silk, or plastic.

These cards feature one or more baseball players, teams, stadiums, or celebrities.

Baseball cards are most often found in the U.S. mainland but are also common in Puerto Rico or countries such as Canada, Cuba, and Japan, where top-level leagues are present with a substantial fan base to support them.

Some companies that are notable for making these cards are Topps, Upper Deck, Fleer, Donruss, Bowman, and Playoff Contenders. 

You Might Want to Check Out; 10 Most Expensive Sports Trading Cards | 2023

What are the Types of Baseball Cards?

If you have a baseball card for sale, you should know the type of baseball card it is. This would help you in knowing the quality and ultimately knowing the price to ask for it.

The types of baseball cards are:

Digital Cards

These cards like the name implies are digital and are offered for purchase exclusively online. 

Base Cards

This is the most basic of baseball cards. They are the individual cards that comprise regular sets. 

Subsets

Subsets are defined by a different design than the traditional base cards or by a printed symbol.

Despite their uniqueness, subsets typically hold about half the value of a player’s base card.

Rookie Cards

Rules regarding rookie cards have changed throughout the years, but at its core, a rookie card is a base card from the first year a player is included in a major set.

As such, these cards carry a premium because there is a higher demand for them. 

Insert Cards

Special edition cards inserted into packs are called inserts. On the back of packs of baseball cards are odds for all the insert cards.

These are smaller specialty sets that, like subsets, feature players who have similar traits, but are rarer than cards in the regular series and hold additional value.

Parallels

Parallel cards are those that use the same photo and design as the base card but implement a small change to make it different.

Basically, parallel cards are often serial-numbered, but can also be found on a per pack or per case basis in some sets

Autographs

A card featuring a certified autograph of the player shown on the front is among the most popular in today’s market.

The cards may be hand-signed by the player, the autograph may be signed on a sticker that is placed on the card by the manufacturer, or the autograph could be cut from a check or other document if the player is deceased. 

Relic Cards

These types of cards will include a custom fabric patch, commemorative coin, etc., produced by the company for a specific set.

The cards are often printed on very thick card stock and can demand a premium.

You Should Also Check Out; 10 Most Expensive Football Cards Of All Time

Is Selling a Baseball Card Worth It?

Yes. Selling a baseball card is worth it.

The money you can get for your collection depends on which cards you have.

The type of card you have would also determine how fast you can sell them. Whether your collection includes modern or vintage cards, you can sell them somewhere.

20 Best Places to Sell Baseball Cards in 2023

#1. Dean’s Cards

This is a company that fully specializes in the sale of baseball cards. The company maintains an inventory of more than 1 million cards, making it the largest online vendor for vintage cards.

The company sells directly, and as such, it can usually pay more money for your cards than you would get elsewhere.

Using Dean’s Cards is possible if your cards are dated before 1969. In some cases, Dean’s Cards will also purchase complete card sets if they are all in their original formats up until the year 1985.

However, it is important to note that Dean’s Cards is open about not often purchasing cards that are newer than 1980 unless they hold special value.

#2. eBay

This is one of the best places to sell baseball cards. On eBay, you can often find a buyer who’s in the market for your specific card.

So if that buyer is online searching for that card, then they could see your eBay listing, and you could make a sale. It is free to list up to 50 items for sale on eBay.

After that, you would need to pay $0.30 per listing. You would also have to pay a 10% commission fee when your cards sell. 

Check this out: 15 Ways To Earn iTunes Gift Cards Legitimately In 2023

#3. Just Collect

This is a website where you can sell vintage sports cards for cash. It buys most vintage cards, which are those from 1979 or earlier.

It only buys certain modern cards, so those produced after 1979. You can use the free appraisal form on the site to get started selling your cards to the company and to find out what your collection is worth.

If you prefer to sell in person, then the company also allows you to drive to one of its appraisal locations or they can drive to you.

#4. Webstore

Webstore is an online auction site that allows you to sell your baseball cards. It has a category just for sports cards.

Basically, Webstore does not charge you fees to list your cards for sale on there.

And, it doesn’t charge you any value fees or commissions either, so you get to keep 100% of the selling price.

#5. Blowout Cards Forum

Another option to consider is the Blowout Cards Forum. It’s a forum where people can discuss collecting sports cards and trading cards.

It discusses buying, selling, and trading baseball cards. So you could post your baseball cards for sale on there, and see what people are looking to purchase.

The good thing with selling through these types of forums is that you can often find targeted buyers many of whom are looking to purchase specific cards.

Plus, you can set your rates within reason of course.

See also: 15 Easy Ways To Get Free Xbox Gift Cards in 2023

#6. Reddit

Reddit is another place where you can find buyers for your baseball card.

On Reddit, there is a SubReddit where people share sports cards and collectibles, and discuss baseball cards in general. It allows you to list cards for sale on there.

The subreddit recommends using PayPal for taking payment. 

#7. DA Card World

This is another site where you can sell your baseball cards online. The company buys sealed boxes and cases of sports cards.

And, it also purchases modern sports card singles.

#8. eBid

Whether you are looking for a way to cut costs and fees when selling your baseball cards or if you want to diversify your selling platforms, one of the best places to sell baseball cards online aside from eBay includes eBid.

Not only is eBid a safe alternative to eBay, but it also boasts a 4.2 rating on Trustpilot, giving it a positive reputation from its community.

#9. Bonanza

Bonanza is another online auction website with more than 25,000 sellers. Although alternative mega-giant auction sites such as eBay boast more than 25 million users, some prefer to use alternative auction sites for increased visibility and a chance to connect with niche audiences.

Using Bonanza is simple and similar to other online auction websites and online communities.

One of the advantages of using Bonanza as a place to sell your baseball cards is the ability to do so without the $.30 fee per listing that eBay charges. 

Read this: 10 Most Expensive Sports Trading Cards | 2023

#10. Kruk Cards

With Kruk Cards, you can get paid for your baseball cards. It’s been buying and selling for over 30 years, making it a well-established place to sell.

The company will assess your cards and give you a quote. It purchases collections large and small. It’s one to consider.

#11. SportsCardPro

This is one of the best places to sell baseball cards in 2023. It is free to list your cards on the site.

Payment is made into your PayPal account, but you would be required to pay a processing fee of 2.9%.

#12. Atomic Mall

Atomic Mall is an online marketplace, like eBay, where you can sell your baseball cards.

The website is rated “Great” on Trustpilot, so it’s a legit place to make money from your baseball cards.

At Atomic Mall, you can also set your price, and anyone interested simply buys. 

13. COMC (Check out My Collectibles)

COMC is an online marketplace for buying and selling sports cards, comics, gaming cards, amongst others.

On COMC, you can create a free account on the site, and then send your cards to the company. You can even set your asking price and respond to offers from buyers.

Once your cards sell, you can choose how you would like to get your earnings. 

14. The Cardboard Connection

The Cardboard Connection is another great option for selling your baseball cards. The company has facilitated the sale of more than $1 million worth of sports cards and collectibles. It purchases lots of different sports cards, including baseball cards.

Once you fill out the form indicating interest in selling your card, The Cardboard Connection or one or more of its vetted network of buying partners will contact you in 1 to 2 business days to learn more about your collection, and to get the buying process. 

See also: How to Check Chipotle Gift Card Balance Easily | 2023

15. Sports Card Forum

Another forum where you can list cards for sale is the Sports Card Forum. The forum has a section for buying and selling baseball cards.

So you could post your cards for sale on there. People even postcards that they are looking for on the forum as well.

So you could have a card that someone is already looking to buy. It is one of the best places to sell baseball cards in 2023. 

16. 2nd Markets

2nd Markets is a website where you can sell your vintage baseball and sportscard collection. It has more than 30 years of experience with buying from the public.

Basically, 2nd Markets only buys large collections, rather than single items or small collections unless they are very valuable.

If you have a large collection of baseball cards to sell, you should consider 2nd Markets. 

17. Local Card Shops

If you do not trust the online process and would simply prefer to sell your cards directly for cash, you could consider local card shops.

If you have any nearby, you could ask them if they are interested in buying baseball cards.

You can also find local card shops where you can sell your baseball cards on Google if there is none near you. 

Check this out: Where To Buy Victoria’s Secret Gift Cards In 2023

18. Yard Sales

Yard sales are a good option because you can tap into a market of people who may not shop online. Plus, you get to set your prices.

If you have some less valuable cards and you’re just looking to get some quick cash for them, a yard sale is recommended. It is one of the best ways to sell baseball cards. 

19. Craigslist

Craigslist is another great option because you can list stuff for sale on there for free.

On Craigslist, you also don’t have to pay commission fees when you sell your baseball cards.

This is its highest selling point and the reason it is considered one of the best places to sell baseball cards. 

20. Pawnshops

If you want to know who buys baseball cards near you, then try your local pawn shop. Many pawn shops purchase sports cards making them a good option.

However, since pawn shops want to purchase items at a lower price to resell them for a profit, they generally won’t offer you the highest price for your cards.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is on a baseball card?

On the back of the baseball card are the team name, player’s name, and statistics. Each brand of card designs the information on the card differently. The number on the back of the card is a numeral between one and a few hundred. This indicates the card is part of a set.

What is the highest amount a baseball card has been sold for?

There are several cards sold for high amounts of money. However, the Honus Wagner card sold for $6,606,000 is the highest amount to date. 

Are baseball cards still a thing?

Yes. Its current deal with MLB as exclusive license holder of league-backed cards extends through 2025. Topps produced the 1952 Mickey Mantle card that sold for $5.2 million last January. 

How much money can I make with a baseball card?

The amount of money you can make on the baseball card depends on the type of baseball card you own. 

Are baseball cards a good investment?

Yes, you can use them as an investment for your future. You can buy baseball cards that will increase in value. First, think of it as a fun way to monetize your baseball card hobby. If you decide to buy baseball cards as an investment strategy, prepare to put in the time.

Conclusion

If you are an avid collector of baseball cards or if you have stumbled upon a potentially valuable collection, knowing the best places to sell baseball cards, both online and near you, can help you to save time while maximizing your efforts as well as the return on your investment.

These 20 best places to sell baseball cards in 2023 are the way to go. 

References

• hobbylark.com
• wikipedia.org
• memory-alpha.fanda

Recommendations

• Best Mystery Shopping Companies In Uk | 2023
• 15 Sites To Buy Discounted Gift Cards
• 10 Places To Buy Gift Card Online With Checking Account
• 10 Best Places To Buy Gift Cards In 2023
• Can You Buy Gift Cards With Gift Cards? Find Out How