Allstate vs State Farm: Which Should You Use?

How do you pick between Allstate and State Farm, two of the most well-known insurance companies? We recently compared the best car insurance companies in the business, and today we’ll evaluate how Allstate stacks up against State Farm in terms of coverage, pricing, and customer service.

We recommend collecting quotes from different providers whenever you browse for car insurance to compare coverage and pricing.

But factors like your age, car make and model, and driving history, besides the insurance provider you choose, might affect your premium, so what’s best for your neighbor might not be best for you.

We will consider the following points to know which we should use between the two. Stay with us.

Check Out: Allstate Insurance Reviews: Is it worth your money

What Are Some Pros and Cons Of Allstate And State Farm?



  • Most policies provide a wide range of endorsements, including commercial insurance.
  • Discounts on homeowners’ insurance are plentiful.
  • Online calculators, resources, and tools.


  • Only two renters insurance discounts are available.
  • With a network of around 10,800 agents, it has fewer agents than State Farm.
  • Individual health and disability insurance are not available.

Pros of State Farm:

  • A nationwide network of over 19,000 agents
  • There are two safe driver reward programs, one geared at inexperienced drivers.
  • One of the few insurance companies that offers roof-related discounts.


  • There are just a few home insurance endorsements available.
  • There are no business insurance riders.
  • Doesn’t provide customer service 24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Check Out This Review of Amica Insrenter’surance: Amica Insurance Reviews: Is it worth your money or not?

What Is The Coverage Like Between Allstate And Farm State?

That both Allstate and State Farm have local agents is a huge plus. Unlike some carriers, you can go to your local insurance office if you want to engage with an agent in person.

You will have the same coverage options whether you browse for auto insurance online or in-person at a local branch.

You may expect to discover the following forms of auto insurance with Allstate and State Farm, as with other car insurance companies:

  • Bodily injury liability (BI)
  • Property damage liability (PD)
  • Collision
  • Comprehensive
  • Medical payments (MedPay)
  • Personal injury protection (PIP)
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM)

Allstate and Farm State also provide the following additional services like:

  • Usage-Based Insurance
  • Gap Insurance
  • Rideshare Coverage
  • Accident Forgiveness (Farm State doesn’t offer this).
  • Roadside Assistance
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Recreational Vehicle Insurance
  • Boat Insurance
  • Travel Trailer Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Umbrella Insurance

When comparing the coverage options offered by Allstate and State Farm, Allstate checks a few additional boxes, such as accident forgiveness and RV insurance. However, if those forms of coverage aren’t vital to you, the firms are neck and neck.

It’s also worth noting that Allstate operates in all 50 states, whereas State Farm only operates in 48. Despite advertising a countrywide presence, State Farm no longer accepts new customers in Massachusetts or Rhode Island.

This review of Classic Car Insurance: What is it? And how does it work? will give you more insight on Insurance coverage.

Allstate Vs. State Farm: Roadside Assistance

Roadside help is available from both Allstate and State Farm. While they both cover the same incidents, the cost of coverage differs. You don’t need a collision or comprehensive plan with State Farm to sign up for roadside assistance. You should expect to spend an additional $5 monthly for the service.

Allstate does not charge a monthly fee and instead charges clients’ peruse. Most Allstate’s roadside help services would set you back anywhere from $79 to $119 per incident. For between $100 and $185, you can upgrade to a premium membership. This plan is more expensive, but it comes with more perks.

Read Also: How to Get Cheap Car Insurance

What Is The Cost And Discounts For Both Allstate And State Farm

When you contact Allstate or State Farm for a car insurance quote, various factors will determine your quote. Here are the factors that will affect your prices with either business besides the coverage you select:

The law requires insurance coverage in every state. The provider considers the dangers in your community besides what your home state requires.

If you add an inexperienced driver to your coverage, anticipate your insurance costs to rise. According to the CDC, the risk of accidents is higher for people aged 16 to 19 than anyone else.


Choosing basic coverage insurance saves you money over having comprehensive and collision coverage.

Deductible: A greater deductible lowers your premiums, but it also means you’ll have to pay more out of pocket if you submit a claim.

Credit score: If you have bad credit, the insurance views you as a risk. It pays to have good credit if you want to get affordable vehicle insurance.

Type of vehicle: If you drive a high-end sports car, expect to pay a higher premium for your insurance. It’s a good idea to seek insurance estimates before you buy a car so you know what you’re getting into. Some cars are simply more expensive to insure than others, such as minivans and other variants.

Driving Record: because of the increased risk, expect higher rates if you have received a speeding citation or have been in an accident.

Although Allstate is usually more expensive than State Farm, this isn’t always the case. The only way to determine how much your insurance will cost is to request a free quote from the supplier.

See Also: GEICO Insurance Reviews 2023: Everything You Need To Know


When comparing Allstate vs. State Farm, the availability of discounts should also be considered. Even if your insurance rates are already higher, the discounts could lower your premium to where you choose that career.

Both Allstate and State Farm provide a wide range of savings compared to other insurance companies. It all boils down to the savings that apply to your specific scenario when choosing a supplier.

See Also: Comprehensive vs Collision Car Insurance: All you should know

What Are The Ratings And Reviews Of Allstate And Farm State?

Based on studies from industry leaders, we can learn a lot about an auto insurance providers. Let’s compare and contrast a few Allstate and State Farm insurance ratings.

Ratings And Reviews

  • It’s an A+ BBB Rating for both Allstate and Farm State.
  • BBB Complaints Last Year: Allstate with 459 and Farm State with 438
  • AM Best Financial Strength Rating: Allstate with An A+, and Farm State with A++.
  • J.D. Power 2020 U.S. Insurance Shopping StudySM Score: Allstate 858/1000 and Farm State with 860/1000.
  • J.D. Power 2020 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction StudySM Score: Allstate with 876/1000 and Farm State with 881/1000.

While it’s a close race, data shows that State Farm outperforms Allstate regarding customer satisfaction, and J.D. Power surveys consistently name State Farm first.

The suppliers’ BBB ratings show they are both in good standing. The number of complaints resolved in the previous year provides insight into consumer satisfaction.

Although their statistics are nearly identical, State Farm is a far larger corporation than Allstate, with a market share of 16 per cent, according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Allstate has approximately 9% of the market.

You’d expect that with nearly twice as many clients, State Farm would have twice as many complaints – but that’s not the case.

Comparing customer evaluations for Allstate and State Farm shows that both firms have positive and bad feedback, which is typical of insurance companies.

Here are two client testimonials that stuck out to us:

Clients Reviews

“I have been with Allstate for 40 years. They carry my auto and home insurance. I would recommend them to anyone.”

– Charlotte K. via TrustPilot

“Love State Farm. All of my insurance, banking, and financial planning is through SF. Quick service, both at the agent’s office and on the phone. Needed a tow. They sent someone ASAP, and no [money] was paid out of pocket for the tow. I had a checking [account] question, and they were available on the phone super late and to chat online as an [instant message]. Love my agent!”

– Anonymous via Trustpilot

What Is Their (Allstate vs. Farm State) Technology Like?

Both establishments have user-friendly generic smartphone apps. You can pay your monthly bill, acquire your insurance ID card, and evaluate your policy using these apps.

Furthermore, both firms provide a safe driving program that offers reduced prices for monitoring devices.


Drivewise: This program analyzes your driving habits and may qualify you for a discount. Get 3% back when you sign up and up to 30% back every six months.

Completing challenges also earns you Allstate Rewards points. If you maintain your speed below 80 mph, minimize late-night driving, and restrict forceful braking, the computer considers you a safe driver.

QuickFoto Claim: After an accident, take images of the damage with your phone and submit the photos to your adjuster.

Roadside assistance: Use the app to request emergency assistance.

Access to your agent: Use the app to contact your agent.

State Farm

Drive Carefully and Save: This program offers a discount for driving safely. Using the app or connecting through OnStar can save you up to 30%.

Upload images: Using the app to upload papers and photos makes filing claims much easier.

In the event of an emergency, contact roadside assistance.

Contact a representative: For further information, contact your local agent.

Which Is Better: Allstate Vs. State Farm?

So, would you rather have a good neighbour in State Farm or be in excellent hands with Allstate?

Both companies offer excellent auto insurance, but we recommend State Farm because of its comprehensive coverage, reliable customer service, and affordable pricing.

Overall Rating

Allstate: 4.0

State Farm: 4.5

Still, getting a quote from both businesses to understand where you stand isn’t a bad idea. What works for most drivers may not work for you.

Methods Of Finding


Our expert review team gathers data from dozens of vehicle insurance providers to produce rankings of the best insurers to give consumers with reliable and unbiased information.

Each of the following categories receives a score and an overall weighted score out of 5.0 stars.

Insurers with good financial ratings and customer-focused business operations get the best ratings in this area.

Availability: We consider availability by state and exclusions for certain types of drivers.

Coverage: They base this grade on the several insurances offered and the maximum coverage limits and add-on plans.

Costs and Discounts: Our research team examines sample quotations from various drivers nationwide. The companies with the lowest pricing and the most auto insurance discounts win the highest marks.

Customer Service: We read customer reviews and consumer feedback studies from companies like J.D. Power.

Automobile insurers that offer mobile apps, innovative internet services, and telematics are more likely to meet customer needs.

How Do You Get A Quote From Both Insurance Providers?

Getting rate quotes is a crucial aspect of comparing insurance carriers. Fortunately, State Farm and Allstate offer online quotations for most of the insurance products they market. If you prefer, you can gain a quotation by phoning an agent.

Each organization follows a similar procedure for obtaining a quote. You’ll be asked to give personal information like your birthday, Social Security number, address, and information specific to the insurance you’re purchasing.

Because Allstate and State Farm work with independent agents, picking one with whom you feel at ease is critical. If you don’t get along with the first agent you talk to, look for another in your region.

The process should take a few minutes, whether you gain a quotation online or over the phone. And, if you get a quotation online, you’ll be able to keep it and return to it later, so there’s no pressure to buy a policy immediately.


State Farm and Allstate are among the best insurance companies you can find anywhere in the world. They have their pros and cons, as has already been spelt out.

However, your choice depends on the reviews, claims, or comments you must have heard or viewed. Making the right choice isn’t far-fetched.


We Also Recommend

Leave a Reply
You May Also Like