Where To Sell Beanie Babies Online For Money | Best Tips

First of all, are beanie babies worth anything? What do you think? If you think they are, we can direct you to sell beanie babies online and make some money. 

If you still think they aren’t worth anything, then we can still direct you to where to sell the beanie babies you have, and if you don’t have any but know someone who wants to sell theirs, then you can rub your palms in joy now as you’ll be selling soon. 

This article discusses the worth, the what, the number, and where to sell beanie babies. There are several places where beanie babies can be sold, and they would be explored here. 

What are beanie babies? 

Ty Warner, the enigmatic billionaire behind toy firm Ty Inc., which he started in 1986, invented Beanie Babies. In 1993, he introduced Beanie Babies, which was originally misunderstood. 

“Nobody really wanted Beanie Babies at first,” admits Lina Trivedi, one of Ty’s first employees. Consumers didn’t appear to understand them, and retailers didn’t think they would fit into their stores’ look. Then, she said, it was as if a switch had been flipped overnight. 

Beanie Babies exploded in popularity in the Chicago suburbs, where Ty’s headquarters were located, and then spread across the country. “You don’t really notice the intensity growing or anything when you’re in the middle of it,” Trivedi adds, “because you’re in the vortex of it all.” 

At the turn of the century, the Beanie Baby bubble burst, and the market’s “animal spirits”, a term coined by British economist John Maynard Keynes, vanished. Because the toys were mass-produced, only a few were truly uncommon, except those from the early generations.  

Price drops spawned more price drops, and the Beanie Baby haze dissipated. As a result, millions of Americans were left with millions of Beanie Babies in their basements, forgetting about them save for the errant thought of what to do with them now and then. 

The market for Beanie Babies didn’t completely disappear after the crash, but it now looks very different – and the great majority of them aren’t worth very lot. There are still costly Beanie Babies on the market; they’re not as well-known as the Princess bear, for example. 

See Also: How To Set Up A Trust in 2023: Facts and Secrets

Why do people like old things? 

Consider it this way: If you have 10,000 songs to listen to, you will probably only enjoy 100-200 of them. It’s just the way we are. Similarly, whether you appreciate movies, art, novels, warcraft, and other forms of entertainment, you will only enjoy roughly 1-2 percent of what is available. 

Well, it dates back about 5,000 years or so in documented history, and they all made stuff like that. If you live for 100 years, that’s only approximately 1/50th of known history, and there’s a fair chance you’ll find something you enjoy better in the 49 out of 50 years you haven’t lived than the 1 out of 50 you have. 

Adding to this is the fact that the old stuff has lasted so long because so many people have found it fascinating throughout the years. The dreck is forgotten while the cream of the harvest is kept.  

You don’t have to pick through all the mediocre Elizabethan playwrights, you just read Shakespeare, the finest, since generations of editors have reviewed old work that has endured, and you don’t have to weed through all the mediocre Elizabethan playwrights; you just read Shakespeare, the best.  

Only the greatest writings of ancient Greek philosophers have survived, so you don’t have to read them all. You don’t need to listen to most of Mozart’s contemporaries; millions have already done so and judged that he is the finest; all you have to do now is listen to him. 

Why do people buy antique items? 

What drives people into buying old items is that they have a sentimental value that they have placed on whatever catches their interest. No matter how much time has passed since their conception, really great human achievements are truly remarkable. One of the most important characteristics of excellent things is that they are ageless and globally applicable. 

In terms of new things, it’s impossible to predict which aspects of our contemporary culture will last for millennia to come. Kendrick Lamar appears to be really good right now, but would someone listening to his words 300 years from now be able to grasp why it was so popular in 2015? Doubtful. 

The majority of new things that may be expected to last are constructed on ‘ancient ideas.’ A new piece of furniture or a new shoe manufactured in a high-tech facility is not meant to last but rather to be ‘quick.’  

A new piece of handcrafted furniture made using classic, tried-and-true techniques will endure a lifetime. It’s made to last, not to be thrown away. 

See Also: Revocable Trust vs Irrevocable Trust: Difference | Best Option For Me

Why do people want to sell their beanie babies? 

According to the scarcity principle, when things are in limited quantity, they become more desired. Ty leveraged the idea of scarcity to create a sense of urgency surrounding Beanie Babies in the 1990s. 

People were led to feel they were in short supply when they weren’t, and once they learned this, the appeal of the situation diminished. The scarcity principle still holds true in the aftermath, albeit in a more realistic way. 

It isn’t a hard-to-find Beanie if everyone is selling the same Beanie, so it isn’t likely to be pricey. Indeed, the most expensive ones are those that the majority of people are unaware of. Some items were never sold in stores. 

How much are people willing to pay for a beanie baby? 

In the last five years, the largest money paid for a Beanie Baby was $7,353.51 for a Chef Robuchon Beanie Baby in 2011. Ty Inc. created the Chef Robuchon bear to honor French chef Jol Robuchon at the launch of the L’Atelier at Four Seasons New York in 2006. 

Ty didn’t say how many Chef Robuchon bears they manufactured, but it’s estimated that there were around 200 in total. 

Where to sell beanie babies? 

#1 – eBay 

Pierre Omidyar founded eBay in 1995. Omidyar had various jobs dealing with software and computers, as well as extensive experience selling on the Internet, in addition to his Computer Science degree.  

He decided to create a page on his website where people could sell items to the highest bidder. The concept was quickly successful, and Omidyar began to amass a sizable fortune. As a result, he quit his job and started selling on eBay. 

Customers were invited to describe the service they received from others when Omidyar launched a rating system. In this way, bad vendors and poor payers could be identified more quickly. 

eBay is now used by millions of individuals all over the world and sells practically anything you can imagine. A rare baseball card sold for $1.2 million was one of many goods sold at exorbitant prices. 

If there’s a place where you can sell your beanie babies, then eBay may just be the place. 

#2 – PlushCollector 

PlushCollector.com specializes in collectible buy-back services for your Ty Beanie Babies, Ty Beanie Kids, Ty Buddies, Ty Boppers, Ty Beanie Boos, Ty Baby Beanies, Ty Jingle Beanies, Ty Pluffies, Ty Classics, Ty Pillow Pals, Ty McDonald Teenies, etc. 

Whether you have a personal collection of plush collectibles that you’d like to pass on to a deserving family or have surplus stock or inventory that you’d like to get rid of, Plush Collector is more than happy to take them off your hands. 

They also cover the cost of postage by providing a free prepaid mailing label with orders of $25 or more. We will buy any collection of any size. 

#3 – Etsy 

Etsy is an online marketplace for handcrafted art and crafts created by individual shop owners. The term “handmade” refers to the seller’s handiwork (or design). It’s a pretty broad term; stringing beads on a wire or putting a simple pendant on a chain are both “handmade.” 

It’s impossible to promote mass-produced goods as “handmade.” That is considered resale on Etsy and is prohibited by their TOUs. Some years back, they altered their definition to allow retailers to use a manufacturer to create their creations. Although Etsy must approve the company you’re dealing with. 

Vintage objects must be at least 20 years old in order to be sold. It is also a great place if you’re looking for where to sell beanie babies. 

#4 – Sell2BBNovelties 

Sell2BBNovelties specializes in purchasing excess inventory, personal collections, shop liquidations, overstock, and closeout items. They want to buy it if you have extra products, a collection, or store inventory that you want to sell.  

They have over 75,000 products listed on their website with the prices they will pay for them. Get a quote right away. There is no such thing as a little or huge collection. 

Toys and collectibles such as TY Beanie Babies, Funko POP! figures, Star Wars action figures, Yu-Gi-Oh cards, Pokemon cards, Barbies, DC, Marvel, WWE Action Figures, Webkinz, LEGOs, and more are now being sought.  

They will also purchase non-toy products such as video games, silver coins from the United States, and other such items. A terrific place if you are in search of where to sell beanie babies. 

#5 – Facebook Marketplace 

Facebook Marketplace is a digital marketplace that allows users to buy, sell, and trade products with individuals in their local region.  

If Marketplace becomes appropriate to your business, you’ll be able to use Marketplace, your own page, and Facebook’s own advertising solutions to take advantage of the one-two punch of Facebook advertising and organic interaction. 

Marketplace allows Facebook users to post photographs of garage sale items and collectibles and explore products sold by local merchants. The sellers set the price, but potential buyers have the option to make a counter-offer. 

The sheer fact that everyone has a Facebook account explains why Facebook Marketplace has become such a popular business tool.  

The ease with which Facebook users who are unfamiliar with Marketplace can begin listing their items on the platform is unmatched by any other digital marketplace. 

Businesses of all shapes and sizes have used Facebook Marketplace to reach out to a bigger audience that would otherwise be unavailable to them.  

One of the most prevalent ways for modern merchants to engage with their customers and earn their trust is to promote their brand on social media channels. Where to sell beanie babies is no longer an issue. 

#6 – Craigslist 

Craig Newmark and Jim Buckmaster founded Craigslist with the goal of providing users with a useful, noncommercial way to connect with others in their neighborhoods.  

Most classified categories on Craigslist are free to post, and browsing and responding to advertisements is also free. 

CraigsList began as a method for its founder, Craig Newmark (a newly minted dot com millionaire), to “give back.” He chose to do so by launching a free classified ad website.  

Because everyone in classified sites was out to make a buck initially with the tired newspaper model of pay for an ad, get eyeballs, this caught people’s attention. There was no one who stood out in the crowd. 

If you have an idea of what you are looking for, in this case, it could be where to sell beanie babies, then Craiglist may just be the place for you. People have gone on Craiglist to get things and ended up with treasures and other very valuable items. 

See Also: What Is Trust Investing? Overview, And How It Works

#7 – Flea Markets 

A flea market is a gathering place for consumers and vendors to swap products and services. That is, in essence, what a market is. Sellers pay a fee to be included on the market.  

Customers gather to purchase goods and bargain with merchants. Anyone can make a sale. Anyone can purchase. 

At a flea market, a customer may be able to wander among numerous “stores” at once and purchase items at steep discounts. You can even haggle for the price you want. Worn clothes and toys are some of the more common products offered at flea markets. 


Because earlier Beanie Babies are rarer than the newest generation of plush animals, they are usually valued the most. However, Beanie Babies must be in immaculate condition, smell excellent, and have their original tags to be sold. 



Leave a Reply
You May Also Like